YA

The One

The One

, , 0

Reggie Reviews The One by Kiera Cass

Synopsis: As the Selection draws to a close, America Singer must go through additional trials, both royal and personal, while her relationship with Prince Maxon grows increasingly complicated.

Warning: SPOILERS AHEAD!

The Review

Negatives

  • The first two chapters recounting America’s seduction attempt were cringe-inducing, and frankly felt a little out of character for her. Throughout the books, America’s self-respect leads her to be horrified at the prospect of potentially performing sexual acts as a way to gain favor with the prince and to knee Maxon in the “crown jewels” when she misinterprets his intentions. Although the seduction idea was formulated by her maids, it seems odd that America would agree to it, since previously her character was vehemently opposed to using her body to win the Selection.
  • King Clarkson’s death felt like an easy way out for America and Maxon to be together. It would’ve been more impactful to see Maxon fighting Clarkson in order to marry America, since it would’ve shown character development on Maxon’s part because he would be willing to argue with his abusive father rather than obey his command. I was eagerly awaiting that moment where Maxon confronts his abuser but unfortunately, it never occurs.
  • The deaths of Celeste and Anne were heartbreaking, but they felt unimportant since each one was addressed in a single sentence and then the plot moved on. Since the story ends on a happy note, with everyone getting a happy ending, I would have liked to see some kind of memorial for Celeste and Anne, potentially giving them a bittersweet ending and the reader a sense of closure.
Me reading the first two chapters
Me reading the first two chapters

Positives

  • Celeste was the main antagonist in the first book, but the way Cass humanizes her in the last book was a welcome surprise. Seeing Celeste’s vulnerability and uncertainty was refreshing and added more depth to the story, since we are able to see her character development and previous motivations through her eyes when she converses with America in the library.
  • The friendship that develops between the four remaining girls in the Selection was a breath of fresh air, since the constant underlying rivalry seemed so isolating, not only for America but for the rest of the girls too. I like the solidarity, respect, and friendship they developed, even while they were competing against each other.
  • The political intrigue with rebels made the story more multi-dimensional and I liked how it was fleshed out in this book, particularly with the revelation that America’s father was a Northern rebel, which led her to start identifying rebels that were in the palace the entire time, like Gavril Fadaye!
  • The resolution of America and Aspen’s relationship near the end of the book was well-executed and felt very authentic. Also, I am glad Aspen got his happy ending with Lucy since overall, he is a good guy.
  • Who doesn’t love a picture-perfect ending?! This book makes sure the reader is content with its conclusion, and I definitely was!
Me while reading the epilogue
Me while reading the epilogue

The Verdict

Reggie Says:

A satisfying conclusion to a series that progressively improved!

The Elite

The Elite

, , 0

Reggie Reviews The Elite by Kiera Cass

Synopsis: America Singer advances in the Selection, becoming one of the Elite, a group of six girls left vying for the position of princess and wife to Prince Maxon Schreave.

Warning: SPOILERS AHEAD!

The Review

Negatives

  • One thing I could not overlook was America’s dishonesty. She never tells Maxon that Aspen is in the palace and part of the guard (and she has many opportunities to do so), even after Maxon bares his soul to her about his feelings regarding the rest of the girls (Kriss, Celeste, Elise, and Natalie) and his relationship with his father. I felt sorry for Maxon during this scene because here he is pouring his heart out to America and coming clean about everything, and she is still holding on to this massive secret. It felt hard to root for her at times, especially when she starts getting jealous when Maxon spends time with the other girls, because her jealousy came off as hypocrisy to me since she essentially does the same thing to Maxon by spending time with Aspen.
Me every time America has a chance to tell Maxon about Aspen but doesn't
Me every time America has a chance to tell Maxon about Aspen but doesn’t

Positives

  • While reading the first book, I wished it was a little more intense, but this second book ramped up the intensity so fast I forgot all about the lack of it in the first book! From the heartbreaking scene with Marlee and Carter to America’s discovery of Gregory Illea’s perfidiousness to the revelation of King Clarkson’s true nature, this book certainly kept me on my toes!
  • Shoutout to America’s father for always supporting her! His letters to her were so sweet and it was refreshing to read about a loving dad in a book full of terrible ones (I’m looking at you, Clarkson and Gregory).
  • Kriss extending a hand of friendship/alliance out to America in the garden was such a kind gesture. I liked how even though Kriss and America are stuck in a system where they are not allowed to make the final decision, Kriss attempts to create some sort of agency for herself by trying to form an alliance of sorts with America.
  • Maxon’s character arc is truly wonderful in this book. The first book did not offer much in terms of Maxon’s characterization, but this second book allows us to see the cracks in his perfect prince armor, the mounting pressure he faces as he readies himself to ascend the throne as king, and the abuse he suffers at the hands of his father. It was heartbreaking to read, but it helped develop his character which I appreciated.
Me when we find out Maxon's father whips him :(
Me when we find out Maxon’s father whips him 🙁

The Verdict

Reggie says:

A fun, thrilling sequel that adds complexity to the main characters!

The Selection Post 2

The Selection

, , 0

Reggie Reviews The Selection by Kiera Cass

Synopsis: America Singer is chosen to participate in the Selection, a Bachelor-like tradition that aims to find the ruling family’s prince a bride.

Warning: SPOILERS AHEAD!

I’ve seen The Selection many times at my local library and like many of us, fell prey to the supposed cardinal sin of reading. I judged a book by its cover! And let’s be real here, we all judge books by their covers. How else would we decide what to read in a hurry?! However, quarantine has left me with a lot of free time and e-books have become my new best friend since libraries are closed. When my friend recommended The Selection, I was hesitant, but she loves it so much and told me I had to give it a chance. So, I did. And here we are!

The Review

Negatives

  • Prince Maxon Schreave was described as just perfect. Throughout the book, I was aching for some flaws, any flaws to humanize him instead of making him this perfect golden boy, especially because we see Aspen’s flaws early on in the story. One instance where he yells at America helped him shed the perfect prince image a little, but I wanted more.
  • I thoroughly disliked the whole concept of America being beautiful, but not knowing it. I’d prefer a female protagonist who knows she is beautiful and talented, but still has humility and grace rather than a character whose ignorance of her own beauty is applauded. I wish she was aware of it but did not let it define her and change her interactions with others. America’s ignorance of her own beauty felt like it was conveying the message that a lack of self-awareness is a good thing to young readers.
  • America stringing along Aspen and Maxon throughout the book  made me dislike her a little. Come on, choose one!
decision

Me to America the whole book

Positives

  • The opulence in the book was a treat for the imagination! I loved picturing America’s (and the rest of the girls’!) dresses while they stay at the palace.
  • I also enjoyed the female friendships in this book, especially between America and Marlee, as well as the friendship America builds with her maids Anne, Mary, and Lucy.
  • Although America made me dislike her sometimes, I absolutely loved America’s boldness. She is unafraid to tell it like it is and express her opinion. I know YA as a genre has an abundance of assertive heroines, but it made me happy to read about another one.
yesgirl

Me when America stood up for her maids

The Verdict

Reggie says:

Worth a read if you like lighthearted royal romances with a dash of love triangle tension.